Independent fashion reviews and reporting, since 2023
FashionScarlet

Beauty.

Skincare, makeup, fragrance and hair tools, judged on ingredient lists, brand claims and what buyers report. We say where the evidence stops.

Beauty is where marketing language runs furthest ahead of evidence, so these pieces are careful about the difference between what a formula contains, what a brand says it does, and what buyers report. Nothing here is medical advice. Persistent skin concerns belong with a dermatologist.

20 articles · 9 reviews · 11 guides
Beauty Review

Cloud Nine review

The British hair-tool maker's straighteners and wands: the range, the price positioning, and how owners rate them over time.

Everything in Beauty

Reviews only
  1. Review

    Imaginary Authors review

    The Portland perfume house's small-batch fragrances: how the range is built, how it's priced, and how long buyers say the scents last.

  2. Review

    Typology review

    The French minimalist skincare brand's short ingredient lists, what its formulas claim, and where buyer feedback is mixed.

  3. Review

    The Ayurveda Experience review

    Ayurveda-inspired skincare sold direct: what the brand claims, what's in the formulas, and what the evidence can and can't support.

  4. Review

    The Ordinary review

    The Ordinary's low-cost, single-ingredient serums: what each is for, how to avoid overlapping actives, and what UK buyers report.

  5. Review

    NUME review

    NUME's hair styling tools: what the range covers, how it's sold, and where customer feedback is concentrated.

  6. Review

    ghd review

    ghd's straighteners and dryers in Australia and the UK: the line-up, the warranty, and how owners rate them.

  7. Review

    Kosas review

    Kosas' clean-positioned makeup and skincare: the hero products, the ingredient claims and buyer feedback.

  8. Review

    GirlGotLashes review

    Lash and brow products sold in Germany: what the range includes and what buyers report about application and wear.

  9. Guide

    Charlotte Tilbury foundation with NARS concealer: does the pairing work?

    Whether Charlotte Tilbury foundation and NARS concealer make a good pairing, and for whom.

  10. Guide

    Dark spots on the face: common causes and approaches

    Common causes of dark spots on the face and the approaches people use. Persistent changes need a dermatologist.

  11. Guide

    Brighter-looking skin: what the routines involve

    What routines aimed at brighter-looking skin typically involve.

  12. Guide

    Lipstick and fashion: a short history

    Lipstick's place in fashion history, from early cosmetics to the modern runway.

  13. Guide

    Fragrance and fashion: how scent became part of the outfit

    How fragrance became part of getting dressed, and how to choose a scent.

  14. Guide

    Facial oils: what they do and who they suit

    What facial oils do, and which skin types tend to get on with them.

  15. Guide

    Removing nail polish without damaging your nails

    Removing nail polish without drying or weakening the nail.

  16. Guide

    Face rollers: what they can and can't do

    What face rollers can realistically do for your skin, and what they can't.

  17. Guide

    Manicures and pedicures: the case for regular nail care

    The case for regular manicures and pedicures, and what to ask for.

  18. Guide

    Makeup basics: an order of operations

    An order of operations for applying makeup, from base to finish.

The Selvedge

An occasional letter from the desk: new reviews, policy changes worth knowing about, and the occasional argument. No countdowns, no "last chance". Unsubscribe in one click.

We use your address only to send this letter. See our privacy policy.