Independent fashion reviews and reporting, since 2023
FashionScarlet

Shoes.

Footwear brands and shapes, read for comfort, construction, and how forgiving the returns are when the size is wrong.

Shoes are the purchase most likely to go back, and the one where a short returns window hurts most. Our footwear coverage weighs construction and materials against what owners report after the first few weeks, and treats a brand's returns terms as part of the product.

8 articles · 4 reviews · 4 guides
Shoes Review

Nisolo review

The leather shoes still have admirers, and the huaraches remain the thing to buy. But this is a brand under new ownership after a foreclosure, and the returns window has shrunk to 14 days. Buy as if you're dealing with a new company.

Evidence: Moderate

Everything in Shoes

Reviews only
  1. Review

    Hey Dude review

    Hey Dude's lightweight slip-on shoes: comfort claims, sizing quirks and durability reports from owners.

  2. Review

    Vessi review

    Vessi's waterproof knit sneakers for Canadian buyers: what the waterproofing claim covers, how they fit, and where they fall short.

  3. Review

    Nike review

    Nike's Australian online store: range, member pricing, delivery and the returns experience buyers describe.

  4. Guide

    High heels: the shapes worth knowing and how they've changed

    The heel shapes worth knowing, and how heel fashion has shifted.

  5. Guide

    How sneakers became the default shoe

    How sneakers moved from sportswear to the default shoe in most wardrobes.

  6. Guide

    Chunky sandals: why the bold footbed caught on

    Chunky sandals and the bold footbed: where the trend came from and how to wear it.

  7. Guide

    Shoes worth spending more on

    Which shoes repay spending more, and what to look for in construction.

The Selvedge

An occasional letter from the desk: new reviews, policy changes worth knowing about, and the occasional argument. No countdowns, no "last chance". Unsubscribe in one click.

We use your address only to send this letter. See our privacy policy.