Independent fashion reviews and reporting, since 2023
FashionScarlet
The cover story Style

The returns policy is part of the price

We read the returns terms of six brands we've reviewed, from 120 days down to store credit only. The differences are bigger than the price tags suggest, and in two cases the figure most of the internet quotes is wrong.

By FashionScarlet Editors2 October 20264 min read

Photograph: K Studios / Unsplash

Reviews.

Research-based brand reviews that keep what we checked apart from what the brand claims and what buyers report.

All 41 reviews
Fashion Review

Vuori review

The joggers are popular for a reason: the fabric is very soft and the cut is easy to wear. The returns policy is one of the most generous in activewear. Where the brand is less convincing is durability at its price, and how quickly support answers when something goes wrong.

Our takeVuori is a good choice if comfort is the brief, and the returns policy takes most of the risk out of finding your size.

Evidence: Moderate Facts checked 2 Oct 2026

Proper Cloth · US store

Proper Cloth review

Proper Cloth's made-to-measure shirts: how the sizing process works, the fabric options and turnaround.

Aje · AU store

Aje review

The Australian label's printed, sculptural dresses: what the range covers, how pricing compares, and what overseas buyers should know before ordering.

Hawes & Curtis · US store

Hawes & Curtis review

The London shirtmaker's US offer: shirt fits and fabrics, suiting basics, and the common complaints about sizing.

For Love & Lemons · US store

For Love & Lemons review

For Love & Lemons' lace and occasion pieces: the aesthetic, the price, and how buyers describe sizing.

MESHKI · US store

MESHKI review

MESHKI's going-out dresses and sets for US buyers, and why the store-credit returns policy deserves attention.

Lee · US store

Lee review

Lee's US denim range, from the regular-fit straight leg to newer cuts, and how buyers rate fit and value for money.

Accessories Review

Oak & Luna review

Oak & Luna's personalized jewelry: metals and plating, engraving, and how pieces wear according to buyers.

How to wear things, how to shop for them, and how to keep a wardrobe working. Practical guidance, not trend forecasts.

From our reporting
A price tag tells you what a dress costs if it fits. The returns policy tells you what it costs if it doesn't.
The returns policy is part of the price

All style

Beauty.

Skincare, makeup, fragrance and hair tools, judged on ingredient lists, brand claims and what buyers report. We say where the evidence stops.

All beauty
Beauty Review

Imaginary Authors review

The Portland perfume house's small-batch fragrances: how the range is built, how it's priced, and how long buyers say the scents last.

Beauty Review

Cloud Nine review

The British hair-tool maker's straighteners and wands: the range, the price positioning, and how owners rate them over time.

Fashion.

Clothing brands, and the clothes themselves. How they're made, how they fit, and what happens when they don't.

All fashion

From the desk.

Short notes on things we noticed while reporting: policy changes, numbers worth a second look, small print.

Nisolo's returns window is now 14 days

Several policy-summary sites still say 30. Nisolo's own page says 14 days from delivery, for unworn items. If you're ordering boots for the season, try them on the day they arrive.

Read more

END. pays the import duties on US orders

It's on the delivery page, and it's rarer than it should be for a UK retailer. What END. doesn't pay is the postage on returns, so the saving only holds for things you keep.

Read more

A 4.3 and a 1.2 aren't the same kind of number

One of our reviews cites a score drawn from more than 134,000 reviews. Another cites one drawn from 88, only 17 of them from the past year. We report both, but we weigh the size of the sample and whether the company invites reviews before we lean on either.

Read more

The Selvedge

An occasional letter from the desk: new reviews, policy changes worth knowing about, and the occasional argument. No countdowns, no "last chance". Unsubscribe in one click.

We use your address only to send this letter. See our privacy policy.