Concealers That Don't Crease Under Eyes
Under-eye concealer is the most difficult makeup product to get right. It has to cover darkness without looking cakey, sit on skin that's thinner than the rest of your face, and survive a full day without settling into lines. Most concealers do one of those things well and the other two badly.
This guide is for anyone whose concealer creases by lunchtime, looks dry by 3pm, or goes patchy over the course of a day. We've picked three at different price points and with different finishes. We haven't tested them on our own faces. What we've done is check what the brands state about coverage, finish and ingredients, what buyers report, and the price per ml — which is the number that matters for a product you use in tiny amounts.
Some links on this page earn us a commission. It doesn't change what we recommend. How that works.
Our take
Pick | Concealer | Size | Price | Price per ml | Best for |
Best overall | Kosas Revealer Concealer | 6ml | ~$30 | ~$5.00/ml | Brightening without creasing |
Best coverage | NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer | 6ml | ~$32 | ~$5.33/ml | Full coverage that still looks skin-like |
Best value | Maybelline Fit Me Concealer | 6.8ml | ~$10 | ~$1.47/ml | A cheap everyday option |
What to look for in an under-eye concealer
Hydration, not just pigment. Under-eye skin is thin and has fewer oil glands, so a dry concealer will crease and flake. Look for formulas with glycerin, hyaluronic acid or squalane. A matte, high-pigment concealer designed for blemishes is usually the wrong product for under eyes.
The finish matters more than the coverage level. A radiant or satin finish reflects light and makes dark circles look softer. A flat matte finish can look dry and emphasise lines. If you want full coverage, choose a radiant full-coverage formula rather than a matte one.
Shade match is the difference between brightening and looking ill. Under-eye concealer should be one shade lighter than your foundation, not two. A shade that's too light creates a grey cast under the eye; a shade that matches your skin exactly doesn't brighten. If you're between shades, go for the one that matches your undertone rather than the lighter of the two.
Price per ml is the honest comparison. Concealer is sold in small tubes — 6ml is standard. At $30 for 6ml, you're paying $5 per ml, which sounds high until you remember a tube lasts months. The Maybelline at $1.47 per ml is a third of the price for a similar amount of product.
The most common mistake: applying too much. Concealer creases because there's too much product in the fine lines, not because the formula is bad. Use a tiny amount, tap it in with a finger or a damp sponge, and build only where you need it.
The 3 picks
Kosas Revealer Concealer

Price and retailer: Around $30 for 6ml at Kosas, Sephora and Space NK. Prices change, so check before ordering.
What it is: A creamy, medium-coverage concealer with a radiant finish, formulated with hyaluronic acid, peptides and caffeine. Kosas describes it as brightening and hydrating, and it's designed for under-eye use as well as spot coverage. It comes in a wide shade range.
Why it made the list: This is the concealer for people whose main problem is darkness rather than texture. The radiant finish reflects light, the hyaluronic acid keeps it from going dry, and the caffeine is there for the under-eye area specifically. It's medium coverage, so it brightens without looking heavy, which is what makes it the best overall pick here.
What buyers say: Kosas Revealer gets strong feedback for the brightening effect and the creamy texture. Buyers describe it as hydrating and easy to blend, and many use it without foundation. The recurring complaint is that it can crease on very dry skin or in deep lines if too much is applied — the fix is a smaller amount tapped in, not a different product.
Fine print: Contains hyaluronic acid, peptides and caffeine. Kosas is cruelty-free and states that its products are made without certain controversial ingredients — check the current product page for the full list. Medium coverage, radiant finish. Patch test first if your skin is reactive.
Good:
· Radiant finish brightens rather than flattens
· Hyaluronic acid keeps it from going dry
· Wide shade range
Weigh up:
· Can crease in deep lines if over-applied
· The highest price per ml here
NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer

Price and retailer: Around $32 for 6ml at NARS, Sephora and department stores. Prices change, so check before ordering.
What it is: A long-standing full-coverage concealer with a radiant, creamy finish. It's one of the most widely used concealers in makeup, known for covering darkness and blemishes without looking flat. It comes in an extensive shade range.
Why it made the list: If you need more coverage than the Kosas, this is the one. The formula is buildable without going cakey, and the radiant finish stops full coverage from looking dry. It's also versatile — it works under the eyes and on blemishes, which the Kosas is less suited to.
What buyers say: NARS Radiant Creamy gets consistent praise for coverage and longevity. Buyers describe it as lasting through a workday without fading, and the shade range is frequently cited as one of the best. The recurring note is that it can look dry under the eyes if your skin is very dehydrated — prep with a hydrating eye cream first.
Fine print: Full coverage, radiant finish. Check the current ingredient list on the product page. NARS is not a cruelty-free brand — check the brand's current statement if that matters to you. Patch test first.
Good:
· Full coverage that still looks skin-like
· Extensive shade range
· Lasts through a workday
Weigh up:
· Can look dry on dehydrated skin
· Not cruelty-free
Maybelline Fit Me Concealer
Price and retailer: Around $10 for 6.8ml at drugstores and Amazon. Prices change, so check before ordering.
What it is: A lightweight, medium-coverage concealer with a natural finish, from Maybelline's Fit Me range. It's designed to be oil-free and non-comedogenic, and it comes in a range of shades.
Why it made the list: This is the cheapest per ml here by a wide margin, and it's a genuinely usable everyday concealer rather than a compromise. The texture is light, it blends easily, and the natural finish works under the eyes without looking heavy. If you don't want to spend $30 on a concealer, this is the one that doesn't feel like a downgrade.
What buyers say: Maybelline Fit Me gets consistent feedback for being lightweight and easy to blend at a low price. The recurring note is coverage — it's medium at best, so it won't cover very dark circles on its own. It's also reported to crease on some skin types, especially if applied heavily.
Fine print: Oil-free and non-comedogenic per the brand. Medium coverage, natural finish. Check the shade range at your local retailer — availability varies. Patch test first.
Good:
· Around $1.47 per ml
· Lightweight and easy to blend
· Oil-free
Weigh up:
· Medium coverage only
· Can crease if over-applied
How to stop concealer creasing
Prep the under-eye first. A hydrating eye cream applied a few minutes before concealer makes a bigger difference than the concealer itself. Let it absorb before you apply makeup.
Use less than you think. A dot the size of a grain of rice per eye is usually enough. Tap it in with a finger or a damp sponge — don't drag or brush it, which pushes product into lines.
Set only where you need to. A tiny amount of finely milled powder on the inner corner and under the eye stops creasing without making the area look dry. Skip powder if your skin is very dry.
Don't powder over a radiant concealer if you can avoid it. Radiant formulas are designed to reflect light; powder dulls that. If you must set, use the lightest dusting possible.
Who should skip these
If you have very dark circles that need colour correction, none of these will fully cover them alone — you'll need a peach or orange corrector underneath. If your under-eye area is very dry, the NARS may be too drying; the Kosas is the better formula. And if you want a concealer for blemishes rather than under eyes, the Kosas is too radiant — choose a matte, high-coverage formula instead.
Questions
Why does my concealer crease?
Usually because there's too much product in the fine lines. Use less, tap it in rather than brushing, and set only where needed. Dryness also causes creasing, so prep with a hydrating eye cream first.
What's the best concealer for dark circles?
A radiant, hydrating formula one shade lighter than your foundation. Kosas Revealer is the best here for brightening. If the darkness is very deep, use a colour corrector underneath.
Is expensive concealer better than drugstore?
Not always. Maybelline Fit Me at about $1.47 per ml is a usable everyday option. The Kosas and NARS offer more coverage and a better finish, but the difference is smaller than the price suggests.
Can you use concealer without foundation?
Yes, and many people do. A radiant concealer like Kosas works on its own for a no-makeup look. Blend the edges well so it doesn't look like a patch.
What shade of concealer should you buy?
One shade lighter than your foundation, matching your undertone. Too light creates a grey cast; too dark doesn't brighten. If you're between shades, match the undertone rather than choosing the lighter option.
Does concealer expire?
Yes — most concealers have a 6–12 month shelf life after opening. If the texture changes or it starts to smell, replace it. A 6ml tube used daily lasts around three to six months.
The bottom line
If your main concern is darkness and you want a brightening finish, choose Kosas Revealer. If you need full coverage that lasts, NARS Radiant Creamy is the one. And if you want a cheap, lightweight everyday concealer, Maybelline Fit Me is the value pick.
Use less than you think and prep the skin first. That's what stops a concealer creasing, not the price tag.
